From: M.Venkatesan,                                     December8, 2009
16, Raja apartments, 15/5A-B.K.N Street,            Ref-2009/11
Westmambalam,
CHENNAI-600 033
 email ID : venkym1@gmail.com

To.The Director,

Department of Pension & Pensioners Welfare,

Lok Nayak Bhavan, New Delhi-110003

ID: singhmp@hub.nic.in;

 spbhatia@dpt-pension.delhi.nic.in

Sir,

              Sub: PSG No. PRSEC/2009/01246 Dt.27.7.2009

              Ref: DOPT OM No.23011/4/2009-P.G. Dt.5^th.Oct.2009

                      Copy of my appeal Ref-95 dt.12.11.2008

                      Copy of my letter to The Secretary Ref-2009/09 dt.22.10.09

I have been instructed to contact you directly to find out the status of my petition referred above. I earnestly request you Sir, to expedite at the earliest and send your reply so as to facilitate me for considering other options.

Thanking you.

Sincerely Yours,

Venkatesan.M

Chennai-33

WPMP IS BEING FILED TO IMPLEAD DOPT OF MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL,PUBLIC GRIEVANCES & PENSION WITH THE PENDING W.P.-10442 OF 2008

"Whistle blowing"- Commerce Ministry’s fraud On Govt. Employees Covered Under CCS Pension Rules-1972

Dear friends,

Every day I get few calls from different regions regarding case status, progress, restoration of pension etc but unfortunately none of them bothers to highlight the fraud committed by the commerce ministry to the concerned nodal departments or the public through the media. Please under stand that we do not want any money but just spend some time to report this fraud to the NODAL departments. Fighting by individuals like me & Saxena will not help.

"If you fight alone, you usually lose," says Col Raj. "Back it up with a team and no one can stop you."  This help only we want to blow the trumpet loudly.
" The department of Pension and Pensioners’ Welfare was created by Rajiv Gandhi 20 years back and was left to the mercy of the Ministry of Finance," rues Jolly. "At present, all its good intentions are crushed by its lack of independent administrative and financial powers."
Systems of Grievance redress machinery, Directorate of public grievances & right to information act-2005 have become a mockery.
Commerce ministry officials committed a big fraud on the govt. employees in the name of SVRS-1994.
The department of Pension and Pensioners’ Welfare created by Rajiv Gandhi 20 years back & DOPT continue to be mute spectators of the constitutional violations committed by COMMERCE MINISTRY ON EMPLOYEES COVERED UNDER CCS PENSION RULES OF 1972.

          So once again I request every one of you to send a copy of the following letter with yr signature/name & address to DOPT/DPPW before November end. ( by post,fax,telegram or email. You can post this in prime minister’s website given in the letter)

Thanking you,

With warm regards,

Venkatesan.M

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

From: (YOUR ADDRESS)                                             (DATE & REF.NO)      

To. The Secretary,

Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pension

North Block, New Delhi - 110 001, Fax : 011-23092432, 23093142,

Sir,

          SUB: ILLEGAL SVRS-1994

          REF: 1. No.134/2005-Estt.(A) 17^th.August 2005,GOIndia.

                  2.F.No.27/8/2007/EO/SM.II,GOIndia. (Ban on issue of unilateral guidelines/instructions concerning methods of recruitment and service conditions by Ministries in violation of established rules and procedures.)

Commerce Ministry’s executive fiat of 21^st.May, 1994 No.3/8/91-EI & EP

Be declared as NULL & VOID as it is neither passed by the Parliament nor approved by the NODAL DEPARTMENTS as required under Allocation of Business Rules & Transaction of Business Rules-1961 (77/3 of constitution).

     Since Export Inspection Council has clandestinely implemented above fiat in violation of all Constitutional provisions & Pension act to cheat the employees Please issue suitable directives to concerned departments to RESTORE THE PENSION RIGHTS as per CCSPR-1972 forthwith.

Thanking You.

Sincerely Your’s,

(TYPE YOUR NAME)

C.C to: PMO √   website: http://pmindia.nic.in/write.htm

Fax to:1. Shri.Shantanu consul-Secretary,M/o Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions √ secy_mop@nic.in

2.Dr. Syamal Kumar Sarkar, Joint Secretary (AT&A), jsata@nic.in √ Fax:011-23092580

                Shri M..P. Singh, Director, spbhatia@dpt-pension.delhi.nic.in √

date 9 November 2009 11:21 subject Restoration of Pension-2009/10 mailed-by gmail.com

hide details 11:21 (3 hours ago)

REF:2009/10

To.Department of Pension and Pensioners’ Welfare
Shri M.P. Singh,Director,
Lok Nayak Bhavan, Room No. 320, 3rd floor,Khan Market,New Delhi-1110003 Tele : 24624802 Fax :  24624802
e-mail: singhmp@hub.nic.in/spbhatia@dpt-pension.delhi.nic.in

Sir,                 Sub:Restoration of Pension Rights
                       Ref:2009/09 Dt.22/10/2009
                       No.23011/4/2009 Dt.05/10/2009 of DOPT

As I have been instructed to contact you directly with regard to my grievance No. PRSEC/E/2009/01246 dated27.7.2009.
Please expedite as soon as possible.
Thanks & regards,

VENKATESAN.M No.
Mob:9444030900
Skype:venkym9971

Please visit http://venkym.blogspot.com
http://citizenscharters-amockery.blogspot.com/
http://prostatecarcinoma.blogspot.com/

Gmail - Appeal to Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pension - venkym1@gmail.com

Gmail - Appeal to Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pension - venkym1@gmail.com: "From: : M.Venkatesan, October22, 2009
16, Raja apartments, 15/5A-B.K.N Street, Ref-2009/09
Westmambalam,
CHENNAI-600 033
email ID : venkym1@gmail.com

To. The Secretary,

Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pension

North Block, New Delhi - 110 001, Fax : 011-23092432, 23093142,

Sir,

SUB: ILLEGAL SVRS-1994

REF: 1. No.134/2005-Estt.(A) 17th.August 2005,GOIndia.

2.F.No.27/8/2007/EO/SM.II,GOIndia.



Commerce Ministry’s executive fiat of 21st.May, 1994 No.3/8/91-EI & EP
Be declared as NULL & VOID as it is neither passed by the Parliament nor approved by the NODAL DEPARTMENTS as required under Allocation of Business Rules & Transaction of Business Rules-1961 (77/3 of constitution).

Since Export Inspection Council has clandestinely implemented above fiat in violation of all Constitutional provisions & Pension act to cheat the employees Please issue suitable directives to concerned departments to RESTORE THE PENSION RIGHTS as per CCSPR-1972 forthwith.

Thanking You.

Sincerely Your’s,

?ui=2&view=att&th=1247ab63c0cdb03a&attid=0.1&disp=attd&realattid=ii_1247ab63c0cdb03a&zw

Venkatesan.M

C.C to: PMO √ website: http://pmindia.nic.in/write.htm

Fax to:1. Shri.Shantanu consul-Secretary,M/o Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions √

2.Dr. Syamal Kumar Sarkar, Joint Secretary (AT&A), jsata@nic.in √ Fax:011-23092580

Shri M..P. Singh, Director, spbhatia@dpt-pension.delhi.nic.in √"

Registration Number : PRSEC/E/2009/01246
Name : Shri Venkatesan.M
Date of Receipt : 27 Jul 2009
Current Status : The petition is transferred
Date of Transfer : 30 Jul 2009
Ministry/Department : Department of Personnel and Training
Officer's Name : Dr. Syamal Kumar Sarkar
Designation : Joint Secretary (AT&A)
Address : Room No. 109, North BlockNew Delhi
Telephone No. : 23094010
Fax : 011 23092580
E Mail : jsata@nic.in
Note: You are requested to further liaise in the matter directly with Joint Secretary (AT&A), Department of Personnel and Training, Room No. 109, North BlockNew Delhi for further information.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
REMINDER-III/2009/08-BY EMAIL

From: : M.Venkatesan, September 25, 2009
16, Raja apartments, 15/5A-B.K.N Street, Ref: 2009/08
Westmambalam,
CHENNAI-600 033
email ID : venkym1@gmail.com

Shri Dr Syamal Kumar Sarkar, Joint Secretary(AT&A),
Department of Personnel and Training
Room No.109, North Block,New Delhi-110001.
Tele : 23094010 Fax : 23092580 E- mail:jsata@.nic.in/sarkardk@ias.nic.in
Sir,
Sub: Illegal SVRS & clandestine actions of Commerce Ministry to cheat the employees covered under CCS Pension Rules-1972.
Ref: 1. PRSEC/E/2009/01246 forwarded to you on 30 July 2009.
2. My subsequent email Ref: 2009/05 Dt. 5 August 2009 with 6 enclosures.
3. Email Reminder-1 Dt.19.08.2009.
4. Fax Reminder-2 Dt.04.09.2009
Please let me know the current status of my petition.
Thanking you,
Sincerely Yours,
Venkatesan.M
Chennai-33

883.Kochi case WP(C) 34008/2005(W) posted for hearing on22/09/2009 in COURT 2A

REMINDER-II/2009/07-BY FAX

From: : M.Venkatesan, September 4, 2009
16, Raja apartments, 15/5A-B.K.N Street, Ref: 2009/07
Westmambalam,
CHENNAI-600 033
email ID : venkym1@gmail.com

Shri Dr Syamal Kumar Sarkar, Joint Secretary(AT&A),

Department of Personnel and Training

Room No.109, North Block,New Delhi-110001.

Tele : 23094010 Fax : 23092580 E- mail:jsata@.nic.in

Sir,

Sub: Illegal SVRS & clandestine actions of Commerce Ministry to cheat the employees covered under CCS Pension Rules-1972.

Ref: 1. PRSEC/E/2009/01246 forwarded to you on 30 July 2009.

2. My subsequent email Ref: 2009/05 Dt. 5 August 2009 with 6 enclosures.

3. Email Reminder-1 Dt.19.08.2009.

Since I have been instructed to liaise in this matter directly with you I earnestly appeal to you to expedite & end my agony. Violations of Commerce Ministry & EIC are placed before you with documentary evidences and kindly inform the actions initiated in this regard as soon as possible.

Please acknowledge the receipt of this letter.

Thanking you.

Sincerely Your’s,

Venkatesan.M

Chennai-33

Post copy confirmation of fax sent by email to: jsata@.nic.in,

sarkardk@ias.nic.in

Fax sent at 11.39hrs

DELHI CASE HEARING POSTPONED FOR DEC.7th.2009 AS COMMERCE MINISTRY DID NOT REPLY.

S.P.SAXENA's case Challenging SVRS Scheme comesup on 2nd.Sep.2009

DELHI HIGH COURT NO. 13
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SIDDHARTH MRIDUL

FOR ORDER
5. W.P.(C) 4740/2008 S.P.SAXENA AND ORS. S.P.SAXENA IN-PERSON
CM APPL. 9142/2008 Vs. UOI AND ORS.

KOCHI CASE COMES UP FOR HEARING NEXT WEEK
AFTER ONAM !!!

From.
Venkatesan.M Ref: 2009/05
16, Raja Apartments,15(5A) B.K.N street,
Westmambalam, Chennai-33
To.
Dr. Syamal Kumar Sarkar, Joint Secretary (AT&A),
Department of Personnel and Training,
Room No. 109, North Block, New Delhi. Mail ID: jsata@nic.in

Sir,
Sub: Illegal SVRS & clandestine actions of Commerce Ministry to cheat the employees covered under CCS Pension Rules-1972.
Ref: PRSEC/E/2009/01246 forwarded to you on 30th.July2009.

As the 1994-SVRS is illegal, DOPT has to take corrective measures by suitable directions to the Commerce Ministry to issue my pension payment order (PPO for Normal retirement benefits or as per 2002 SVRS circular) from the date of my relief-19.07.1994.
Please expedite as soon as possible.

Thanking you,
Sincerely Your’s,
Venkatesan.M
5 August 2009

Enclosures:
1. Copy of MANIPULATED CIRCULAR OF EIC issued to all employees.
2. Copy of Original Commerce Ministry circular recd. under RTI Act-2005.
3. DOPT letter No.134/2005-Estt (A) Dt.17.08.2005.
4. Copy of SVRS issued by DOPT, circulated to EIC employees in 2002.
5. Copy of DOPTcircular.F.No.27/8/2007/EO/SM.II Dt.28.12.2007.
6. Copy of EIC letter rejecting my settlement offer.

scan-news artcle0001.pdf - Powered by Google Docs

scan-news artcle0001.pdf - Powered by Google Docs

MOCKERY OF CITIZEN’S CHARTERS!!!
&
CALLOUS ATTIUDE OF DOPT/DARPG
Hon’ble Presidentji,

Sub: Illegal VRS/Clandestine actions by Commerce Ministry

Namaste. You are the custodian of Pensions Act-1871 which protects the rights of pensioners. I am a senior citizen not begging for alms but fighting for my pension rights (covered by CCSPension Rules-1972).
Export inspection agency, under the Commerce Ministry has fraudulently introduced a SVRS in 1994 without involving the DOPT (department of personnel & training) in violation of Constitutional provisions-Art.77/3.

DOPT under the direct control of the Hon’ble Prime Minister is avoiding its responsibility. Instead of using its Super ordinate powers to declare the Subordinate Commerce Ministry’s SVRS-1994 circular( an executive fiat) as NULL & VOID, pushing me from pillar to post.

I am prepared to surrender my ILLEGAL benefits received with interest to accept my normal retirement benefits (47A) which is permitted by treasury rules.
I request you to end my long agony by directing DOPT to redress my grievance expeditiously.

Thanking you.
Sincerely Your’s,


(Venkatesan.M)
16,Raja Apartments,15(5A) B.K.N street,
Westmambalam, Chennai-33
Sunday, 2009-07-26
Ref:2009/04

F. No. 27/8/2007/EO/SM.II Government of India Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions (Department of Personnel an

F. No. 27/8/2007/EO/SM.II Government of India Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions (Department of Personnel an

KOCHI CASE LISTED today in COURT ROOM 6C - 13/07/2009
881. WP(C) 34008/2005(W) SMT.SUMATHY DANDAPANI (SR.)/

STORY OF AN ENCOUNTER ON CONSTIUTION
Commerce Ministry’s fraud On Govt.Employees Covered Under CCS Pension Rules-1972
HOW THE COMMERCE MINISTRY VIOLATED THE CONSTITUTION!!!
I was a govt. employee of Export Inspection Agency-a statutory body under Commerce Ministry, covered by CCS Pension Rules of 1972.In 1994 over 700 employees opted for SVRS & govt. partly settled retirement benefits till 1997. We filed cases for not effecting full payment of attended benefits.
Simultaneously after 11years of my efforts I got an original circular of Commerce Ministry dt.21/05/1994 under RTI Act-2005 which exposed that the 1994-VRS scheme itself is not an approved one by the Nodal depts. Also the commerce ministry’s executive fiat which was circulated among employees was deliberately edited by the officials to cheat the employees. So the circular is NULL & VOID & the scheme is ILLEGAL as the Commerce Ministry has violated all the constitutional provisions.
From 2005 I have been approaching various govt. agencies for Justice. With no tangible solutions forthcoming I filed a fresh writ in Madras high court which is still pending. My efforts for a negotiated settlement also failed. My appeals to the Hon’ble PM-incharge of ministry of Personnel, Public Grievance & Pension, and the Hon’ble President-custodian of Pension Act-1871 did not receive the attention.
Pension is not a bounty and ministry officials cheated the employees by circulating an executive fiat which suppressed the facts to deprive our fundamental right to pension. When one time legislators demand pension, the govt. employees who have worked for over 20years have been fooled by the fraudulent SVRS-1994 circular.
AWAITING JUSTICE TO END OUR MENTAL AGONY
"There are precedents from other countries where pension has been treated as a human right and the Human Rights Commission has awarded relief to the pensioners. In our case the RIGHT TO PENSION has been ROBBED OFF stealthily. Hence, it is requested that NHRC, India may take up the above grievance of VRS OPTEES and award them the necessary relief early".

This is a classic example to prove that much trumpeted grievance handling system of the Govt. of India is just a FARCE. A MOCKERRY OF FRIENDLY CITIZENS CHARTER!!!!!!

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Shri.Rahul Khullar,
Commerce Secretary,
Dept. of Commerce,Udyog Bhavan,
Rafi Marg,New delhi.
Ph:011-23063664,17
Fax:011-23061796

Pray/Relief sought:
To sanction Pension & other benefits after adjusting the excess payments made through 100% commutation.
NATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION Faridkot House, Copernicus Marg New Delhi, INDIA. PIN 110001 Tel.No. : 011-2338 5368 Fax.No.: 011-2338 5368 Telegraphic Add: HUMANRIGHTS Homepage: http://nhrc.nic.in ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Dated: 3rd.July2009.
The Commission has recieved your complaint and it has assigned diary number as 09947

*Some citations of the Supreme Court judgments &
Andhra Pradesh high Court judgment on Tuesday 27.7.2004
in their order on Writ petitions Nos.13680,16407,23938 of 2001 & 6122 of 2002
1.All India Reserve Bank Retired Officers Association vs.Union of India—AIR 1992, SC 767): Hon.Mr Justice Ahamadi reasserted: “The concept of pension is now well known and has been clarified by the court time and again,. It is not charity or bounty nor is it gratuitous payment solely dependent on the whim or sweet will of the employer. It is earned for rendering long service and is often described as deferred portion of compensation for the past service. It is in fact in the nature of a social security plan to provide for the December of life of a superannuated employee”.

2.D.S.Nakra case: The Supreme Court held that pension is neither a bounty nor a gratuitous payment depending solely upon the sweet will or grace of the employer. It is a right and its payment does not depend upon the discretion of the Government. Entitlement to pension to government servants being the product of statutory rule is an enforceable right. Pension is paid as a monthly benefit for past satisfactory service rendered while the employee was physically and mentally alert and in expectation that he would be looked after in the fall of life.
Classification of pensioners will have to answer the test of Article 14 of the Constitution, further held the court……
…..the Supreme Court concluded, pensioners for the purpose of pensionary benefits form a class. Such homogeneous class could not be arbitrarily divided when the pension undergoes an upward revision. The fixation of the cut off date was arbitrary ..... The division classifying pensioners into two classes is not based on any rational principle, held the Court.
3.Writ petitions Nos.13680, 16407, 23938 of 2001 and 6122 of 2002.Ramachandra Raju and others vs. Government of Andhra Pradesh: The Fifth Central Pay Commission also required that as pension is not in the nature of a dole, it should be fixed, revised, modified and changed in ways not entirely dissimilar to the salary granted to the serving employees. A fortuitous circumstance of the date of retirement cannot constitute a legitimate ground for classification, and a classification founded on such fortuitous circumstance would not stand the test of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.
4.R.L.Marwah vs.the Union of India and others: The Supreme Court held that in the absence of any acceptable explanation or justification, the classification of pensioners who were working in the Government/autonomous bodies into two classes merely on the basis of the date of retirement is unconstitutional .....
5.Indian Ex-services League and others vs. the Union of India and others: The Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Nakra held that the pensioners constitute a homogeneous class and the benefits of liberalized pension should be extended equally to all retirees, irrespective of their date of retirement and could not be confined only to those who retired on or after the prescribed date. As a result of this ratio, the Supreme Court in Nakra struck down the relevant parts of the OM which confined the liberalized benefits to retirees on or after a specified date and extended the benefits to all retirees covered by the pension scheme.

6.Supreme Court judgment on 9.9.08 in Baines case:
“….The question regarding creation of different classes within the same cadre on the basis of the doctrine of intelligible differentia having nexus with the object to be achieved, has fallen for consideration at various intervals for the High Courts as well as this Court, over the years. The said question was taken up by a Constitution Bench in the case of D.S. Nakara (supra) where in no uncertain terms throughout the judgment it has been repeatedly observed that the date of retirement of an employee cannot form a valid criterion for classification, for if that is the criterion those who retired by the end of the month will form a class by themselves. In the context of that case, which is similar to that of the instant case, it was held that Article 14 of the Constitution had been wholly violated, inasmuch as, the Pension Rules being statutory in character, the amended Rules, specifying a cut-off date resulted in differential and discriminatory treatment of equals in the matter of commutation of pension. It was further observed that it would have a traumatic effect on those who retired just before that date. The division which classified pensioners into two classes was held to be artificial and arbitrary and not based on any rational principle and whatever principle, if there was any, had not only no nexus to the objects sought to be achieved by amending the Pension Rules, but was counter productive and ran counter to the very object of the pension scheme. It was ultimately held that the classification did not satisfy the test of Article 14 of the Constitution….”

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

statutory right of the employee is enforceable through courts.. The supreme court has declared pension as one of the fundamental rights.

From: M.Venkatesan, To. Hon’ble Chief Justice,
16, Raja Apartments,15-BKN street, Madras High Court,
Westmambalam,Chennai-600033. Chennai-600104.
Fax No.24957230/25332101
Sir,
Sub: Appeal-II for early hearing-submitted
Ref: WP.10442 of 2008
Appeal-I to Hon’ble CJ dt.18.03.2009.

Namaste.
I am a senior citizen & cancer patient fighting for my right to pension which was deprived stealthily by an executive fiat of Commerce Ministry in 1994. My first WP.16155/1997 filed for pension benefits. During its pendency I got hold of certain documents under RTI Act-2005 which exposed that SVRS-1994 scheme itself is ILLEGAL & in violation of all constitutional provisions. As I could not change the prayer in the final stage, I was forced to file a fresh WP.10442/2008 as the cause of action is totally changed.
Now 15years elapsed since my retirement and my fear is that, will I get the justice before my end? Under these circumstances I pray your lordship to consider my appeal favorably for early disposal of my WP on merits.
Thanking you.

Truly Yours,


Venkatesan.M
27th.June2009,
Chennai-33.

c.c to. Shri.KR,advocate/ Shri.KV,PS to HCJ

Kochi case hearing comesup on 29th.June ,Monday
COURT 3C ( 17) 29/06/2009
916. WP(C) 34008/2005(W) SMT.SUMATHY DANDAPANI (SR.)/

& CM.Appl. 7750/2006 SRI.P.PARAMESWARAN NAIR,ASST.SOLICITOR
& CM.Appl. 2963/2007 SRI.P.PARAMESWARAN NAIR,ASST.SOLICITOR

My nominee for RTI Awards-2009

Shri. Wajahat Habibullah, Chief Information Commissioner,

STORY OF AN ENCOUNTER

HOW THE COMMERCE MINISTRY VIOLATED THE CONSTITUTION!!!

I was a govt. employee of Export Inspection Agency-a statutory body under Commerce Ministry, covered by CCS Pension Rules of 1972.In 1994 over 700 employees opted for SVRS & govt. partly settled retirement benefits till 1997. We filed cases for not effecting full payment of attended benefits.

Simultaneously after 11years of my efforts I got an original circular of Commerce Ministry dt.21/05/1994 under RTI Act-2005 which exposed that the 1994-VRS scheme itself is not an approved one by the Nodal depts. Also the commerce ministry’s executive fiat which was circulated among employees was deliberately edited by the officials to cheat the employees. So the circular is NULL & VOID & the scheme is ILLEGAL as the Commerce Ministry has violated all the constitutional provisions.

From 2005 I have been approaching various govt. agencies for Justice. With no tangible solutions forthcoming I filed a fresh writ in Madras high court which is still pending. My efforts for a negotiated settlement also failed. My appeals to the Hon’ble PM-incharge of ministry of Personnel, Public Grievance & Pension, and the Hon’ble President-custodian of Pension Act-1871 did not receive the attention.

Pension is not a bounty and ministry officials cheated the employees by circulating an executive fiat which suppressed the facts to deprive our fundamental right to pension. When one time legislators demand pension, the govt. employees who have worked for over 20years have been fooled by the fraudulent SVRS-1994 circular.

As the RTI Act-2005 helped me to expose the Commerce Ministry’s fraud on employees I nominate Shri. Wajahat Habibullah,Chief Information Commissioner, on behalf of over 700 employees for the RTI Award-2009

For more details please visit : http://venkym.blogspot.com/

M.Venkatesan,16-Raja apartments,15(5A)Balakrishna Naiken street,Westmambalam, Chennai-600033.

GIST' OF 'SPECIAL' LEAVE' PETITION' FILED' ..ADMITTED 'ON4th.MAY' IN 'SUPREME' COURT.

PLEASE' CLICK 'ON 'THE' IMAGE 'TO 'MAGNIFY

..

Click image to Magnify